View forum thread

AndyP whispered to me on Day1 and told me you (FS) thought HanSo7o (1) and BS (3) were a pair (you did tell AndyP this correct?). How would an investigator have this information? Not that hard to deduct from that that you had to be the Fortune Teller (if not bluffing).

I think you are town, so it makes my defense hard. but at least the above is an answer to your query.

I was going for a Princess Bride double bluff. I said I would protect who the town told me to protect. And I did. Did it work, we don't know.

Agreed, comparing to yourself was smart.

Wouldn't I have done this last night before there was immense heat on me and I had just survived the lynching by the town with only 2 votes up votes? If there was a Spy I would know he was Ravenkeeper (either was I knew he was due to out Whispers).

You're good, fedyshen. I'm surprised I still haven't been able to make you crack. PS cracked much earlier than this.

The pairing of Han and Berry was down to the way they interacted on Day 1, but yes, I suppose it's possible that a town player without perfect information could think I had fortune told them on Night 1.

But I made it pretty clear that I only thought they were a pair. What's more, Fortune Tellers get told only when they hit the demon. They get nothing about minions at all. I would not assume that because I got a "Yes, one of them is the demon" result that both of them are evil. A good try, but this defence doesn't quite hold water. Really good effort though, well done.

I'm sure this option was on your radar, but the play of solidifying your claim of Monk was probably more appealing. If I hadn't turned the spotlight on you today, I believe a fair amount of the town would have agreed that you must have blocked the kill, and you'd have your alibi.

You also knew that BlueBoar was Ravenkeeper from the whisper, and killing him would have given him a free guaranteed clear on me. He would have definitely chosen to look at my character given his suspicion of me earlier in the game and the fact that my information is so vital to confirm as real. By killing him, you'd have taken the heat off of me, which you didn't want. You were hoping I would be executed today and you could kill tonight, leaving 3 players left, one of whom would have been Super who has misclaimed his role when he bluffed, and the other would be Berry who I had a Demon read on. You, meanwhile, would be the valiant confirmed townie that saved FS from death overnight. You probably hoped I'd have been on your side from that point onwards as well.

No, I rather think you valued the alibi higher than the kill, especially with PS suspicious of your relationship with AndyP.

It's OK, fedyshen, you can come clean now. It's important to acknowledge when you're beaten, after all.

Got it in one (well, after calling me all the evil names under the sun )

I might well have missed it in, but fedyshen have you explained your vote for AndyP last night? Being the only person against the grain isn't suspicious on its own, but in context it certainly could be

Just to add to the suspicion, as it doesnt't actually prove anything: fedyshen mentioned in our whisper on day 2 that BB told him he wanted to whisper me. In our recent whisper, I asked BB if he mentioned to anyone that he wanted to whisper me, which he denied. Strange, eh?

Well, correct me if I'm wrong - I get a choice too lol.
Bad play? Again, it was a choice I made.

Was the decision to kill me on Day 1 correct too... I am seriously doubting it was, as it gained the twon nothing without verification. This is almost impossible within this game, so keeping a townie alive would be better than killing them.

Chyper shooting PS, is as valid as my execution IMO. One of us is drunk, so moving all three suspects would have been better - aligning them in a bar until someone can let them out one by one and stand by them. We have all played poorly.

Your role has continually spun most and all equations of what could and couldn't be... as I have said, I'll admire your role at the end if Demon. However, it has done little to help any of new, or unsure in terms of trusting you. I still don't lol...

Alas, I watch the finale...

FS claiming BS is the Mayor....



Fedyshen confirmning BS is the Mayor...

I can confirm too that in the first chats with BS, he revealed to me he is the Mayor too. He kind of hinted at it, regarding a post relating to the advice of keeping him in the game until the latter stages. Both of you, if Demon, would know this... and would likely make BS a target for the Night phase after or including tonight.

Funny how you both knew this though

In that case my contingency would have been to get the GunSlinger to kill me. If im tricking you the demon still dies. If i am truly the Saint the town avoids a humiliating execution.

There is a certain amount of doubt in my mind that the assumption I am making here is correct, but Firesilver seems to be giving things away now, such is his confidence in the muddy water he has left behind.

Such as saying that town have been killing town and that the spy doesn't appear evil to the empath. Sadly both these things are true and we have been rather dumb collectively.

In my opinion, if we vote Firesilver today, it will be a bad thing as he has quite clearly been leading us down the garden path with his long posts and his indecision in discussion. I think he is sacrificing himself to allow his boss the chance to win the game.

Does anyone else see this or am I wrong?

I did consider FireSilver might be tricking us, but I would say it is a small chance of that actually being the case unless im getting it wrong. Maybe he is using my trust in him to manipulate me but I doubt it. If he has pulled it off then fair play to him i guess.

If FS is the spy, he would want... no, not want... NEED! to appear opposite to his boss, to ensure that if either are rumbled, they will be polar opposites.

Further, PS said that Fedyshen appeared to be coaching AndyP and this may have been deliberate by Fedyshen to get a townie killed and it worked... we all believed PS (I certainly did anyway) and he went to the block.

Firesilver nominating himself with the cover story that it will confirm me 100% good, is another clue to his intentions. I don't need to have town 100% confirm me and if I'm wrong on this, then i'm sorry and will get everything that's coming to me.

But I really do think that FS needs to die and is sacrificing himself for his boss... and the clearest clue he has given that he is bad, is he was sat next to PS, who was the empath and he knew PS wouldn't be able to detect him as bad. He actually said that!

Saying what he said is like leaving a calling card, to say I did this!

It's a middle finger to everyone playing (no offense FS)

I'd like Firesilver to nominate Fedyshen, please.

Why?

Firesilver has thrown enough dirt at Fedyshen to want to nominate him, but he hasn't so far. Instead, he is throwing himself under a bus. Does anyone wonder why that is, or is it just me?

I have given some valid reasoning before this post, but I am still open to be corrected with something or anything I may be missing, such as...

If I am right, then either FS or fs is the boss, but could the boss actually be daring us to vote him off right now, or is he (more likely) trying to save his boss?

Can someone please nominate fedyshen then all vote for him so we can get this over with.

Don?t vote for FS for goodness sake. We don?t need this to go on for another night and day.

I'm with you. If we wait for FS to explain his "i'd like to nominate myself" instead of actually saying "I nominate myself" we could be here all day waiting...

You sniffed this out before I did. All I have done is join the dots to arrive at my conclusions. Do you want to do it, or shall I? I think you are more deserving of some glory for putting us on what appears to be the right path.

Unfortunately, I can?t nominate anyone BB

Oh bugger. Ok, i'll do it.

Good man.