View forum thread

Also, I didn't mention this at the time...


Thanks Han, I won't forget it

Thankyou TG2 for your time and everyone for the fun.

Was indeed a tough game, and I was convinved FS was not a townie lol... sorry! At least I guessed right with PS being Drunk and trusting BS.

Ha! Another I got right lol...

I agonised for ages over what to do when chyper joined, I'd originally got in mind he could replace anyone inactive and Super was kinda quiet. I was paranoid you were about to execute the saint just because you had no other good targets and he was quiet. In the end I decided Super was just about engaging enough to leave him in asnd you had pulled votes away from him in the Day 1 vote.

Then I was torn between which Traveller to make Chyper; a Gunslinger, a beggar or a Scapegoat. Scapegoat basically dies instead of someone else who's been executed from their same team. I was thinking this would help me to not end the game if/when the Saint was executed. Instead I decided a Saint loss would just be funny for everyone so left it in as an option.

Gunslinger would rush the game along, part of me at that time thought Good was so far off the right path that a random shot in the dark might be their only hope (as opposed to one person who suggested that Good had the game sewn up so Chyper must have been Evil to try and save it!).

Beggar is a fun one where people can donate their dead votes to the Beggar, in return for the beggar learning their alignment. Would have made Chyper central to the game and he'd have had all of the best info. Beggar's can't be drunk or poisoned either so he'd know is info was true. I decided this was too powerful to solve the puzzle of all the info in the game so left it out.

Thanks TG!

Allowing dead players to talk and vote and not knowing what their roles were made the game?er? interesting (and different!)

I said sorry to BB but I should also say sorry to you too, Han. I did it deliberately and it obviously worked wonders messing with your head. TG did say that good can bluff just as much as evil, after all.

A great game played by fedyshen and AndyP as well. In the end, the roles you claimed made it possible to work out what was going on, but to genuinely guess the setup that well without a spy is quite the feat.

I am so glad I chose to pick the two most dangerous players in my view, PS and BB, on Night 1. Without that key information I think I wouldn't have been able to piece it all together. I still got it a bit wrong thanks to evil's cunning, and if they had poisoned me at random on Night 1 I think we would have lost because of my gamble play of deliberately being suspicious.

Well played everyone. Yes, even you, psycho Gunslinger.

Nice - thanks TG.

Well played everyone, particularly FS.

That was quite the game. Thanks, TG!

After seeing all the roles and rules and getting the mayor character which has an incentive to stay alive until late game, I hoped for a bit of an easy start to the game to get a grasp on it. But right away Han mentioned PS and me and requested a whisper with me... I don't think it was a bad move, but for me it meant the end of my strategy. I still don't know how I survived, but it stirred up the game enough to get some reads, I guess.

Although I survived that one, I was kind of clueless as to who actually were evil. I didn't believe both Andy and FS were good at all at some point and I didn't see the point of making the mayor drunk, so I was quite sure PS was the drunk and I could trust my role.

In the end I think we as town should credit FS for all the thoughts and work he put in, as I was (and I think most of us were) completely off track otherwise. Well done, FS!

And cheers to all the others as well, good game!

Cheers, Euro and Berry. I always play games to win, so yes, I put in a lot of thought and effort to the game.

I can't help but remember that PS had it all figured out way before anyone else and let me play detective, though.

All I did was point the finger of suspicion. You did all the hard work in building the detailed case for the prosecution.

A well done to fedyshen for a very spiirited defence!

Hey Firesilver,

I believe I too owe you an apology. For some reason I mistook you for a right royal pain in the arris, so my apologies for giving you such a hard time.

You took it pretty well which is all credit to you, but if it wasn't for TG2's thorough explanation of what went down, I think I'd still be pointing the finger at you now.

I still hate your long posts though...

Good game everyone... especially Fedyshen and AndyP.

To get a glowing reference from TG2 despite ending on the losing side is a genuine badge of honour, so very well done guys.

First time you correctly identified my character all game BB


Understandably. It was, as I said, intentional, so no apology is needed


Also understandable

TG2. Many thanks for being a brilliant host of this game. I didn't play it too well personally, as whilst I had free time, I also had a few too many distractions, plus a few days away where I was limited to evenings.

However, it do enjoy a challenge and this one certainly delivered on that. Thanks also for the well chosen words of advice, but whilst I had sort of worked out a strategy for my role, I could never quite work it into words.

I think Firesilver certainly made up for where others like myself were found wanting and I think on the balance of play... (well, this is ItsAGoal) ...he should be man of the match!

Thanks TG and all the players for a fun ride. I missed the last 24 hours but looking at TG's explanation as to what went on well done on figuring out the baddies!

Good game guys. I definitely fumbled at the start of the game but things just fell into place anyway once AndyP blundered the fact he didnt say anything to FireSilvers claim of Investigator. I did believe FedyShen was the Monk, but once FireSilver got his read on him it was pretty much game set and match.

I think it was you who made the first connection with Andy and got us on the right path. So well done you!

Lots of fun.

Thanks all!

No idea how PS Sussed us out so fast!I feel like all of my words were defendable. My only full mistake (that I noticed) was when I wrote after night 2 saying I pre-prepared this note (and it acknowledged that no one died). Definitely a slip up that I?m impressed FS caught. Well done.

My logic for not killing anyone the last night was to hopefully build trust. Killing the Mayor would lead to someone else being killed. FS was my best change of convincing others he was evil.

Well done to the good team. You really cornered me. As much as I feel I didn?t fully trip up, it became to hard to push alternative theories.

For me, the key was trusting FS absolutely from the off. (I tend to do this in this sort of game - trust someone dtraigjht away) From there and after I had time to think about my night 1 result I realised I was drunk and that I'd received a false result from TG., So, seeing as trusted FS, it could only be that Andy was evil. Working out his character was a bit tricky butwhen FS started reveealing his anomolous results I realised Andy could be the poisoner.
Then, when we waiting for Andy to put a claim in, I thought your post just before he did so reeked of coaching which put my suspicion of you as the Demon front and foremost.

Of course, I could have been horribly wrong about everything...

Well, PS, the reason I fortune told you on Night 1- and then tried my hardest to push you on Day 2- was for almost the exact same reason. I also wanted someone to trust, and if you're going to pick anyone, you pick the best player in the game... but try to make as sure as you can first that you're not being duped! I also tried to do the same for BlueBoar but he was a poor choice as he hates me long posts and never trusted me back

I genuinely thought that evil knew too much to not have a spy, but it was actually down to absolutely top class whispering. I was convinced a red herring saint was just like TG though, so I didn't feel uncomfortable even when I was poisoned!

Misreading the poisoner role (which isn't actually very clear IMO- what does today and tomorrow mean, exactly, TG?) could have caused me some real crises of confidence again on Day 3 if I hadn't felt so sure of the Spy.