| Quote: Originally posted by FiresilverI've been whispering to TG all game about my thoughts and strategies. He must have been giggling his head off the entire time, knowing that he set me up to do exactly what I've done.
I'm not happy with myself. Time to go and suffer at work to make myself feel suitably punished for my hubris 
I think we should try and execute someone else today, so if you really want to go... | |
|
| Of course I don't want to, but I also want to win, and my lynch would benefit the town at this point in many ways.
It would also reduce the number of town information gathering roles the Demon needs to kill, but that's my own fault. | |
|
| I'm going to leave the rest of the town to decide on whether I'm too suspicious to be allowed to live, but I will say one last thing before work.
If you leave me alive for now, and lynch me if I'm still alive when there's 3 players left... well, the Demon then has to decide whether to kill me at night (to remove my powerful role from finding him) or leave me alive (in the hope that he also reaches the last 3 players and gets an easy win by getting the rest of the town to vote me off).
That's the only good thing that I can see coming out of this.
Oh yes, and Andy, if you could reveal all your information now, that would be great please. We've already seen that Investigator is an easy role to bluff if you only reveal partial information. What were your two names and what role is the minion, please? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by FiresilverOhhhh. Yeah, I've played this terribly. I thought you were hinting at Empath to me in your whisper yesterday. I thought PS had done the same to me and that one of you had to be lying.
I think I'm going to leave the rest to the experts (that is, PS). I'm the fortune teller, and the only player I trusted and have shared my role with may be evil
I got a Not Demon result on pleasantsurprise and BlueBoar on Night 1 and a Demon result on BerryStraw and JustSuper on Night 2.
Please can someone else (preferably PS) piece all this information together for now. I have to get ready for work. 
Your night 1 result is correct. Your night 2 result looks wrong (despite Super?s play) because I don?t believe BS is the Demon. Han, sorry but can you remind me what your Night 1 result was again please.
Something happened to make your night 2 result wrong. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by Firesilver
Of course I don't want to, but I also want to win, and my lynch would benefit the town at this point in many ways.
It would also reduce the number of town information gathering roles the Demon needs to kill, but that's my own fault.
I think we should execute someone other than you, but you can also prove your innocence by going.
We are at 7 + 1 (I am the 1) right now - tomorrow we could be at 4 + 1 (or at 5) but still with 8 good votes. Not bad odds as far as I'm concerned. | |
|
| Why can't Super be the Monk?
Feel like I am missing something obvious here.... | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by pleasantsurprise
Your night 1 result is correct. Your night 2 result looks wrong (despite Super?s play) because I don?t believe BS is the Demon. Han, sorry but can you remind me what your Night 1 result was again please.
Something happened to make your night 2 result wrong.
Why do you think Night 2 is wrong? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by AndyP
Wow...I've just read all the posts. I think it's on me to reveal my role then.
I've never played this before so don't know if this is a good idea or not.
I'm the investigator so got an idea of who the minion might be.
Care to share the actual info you have now that you have role claimed? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by Euro
Why can't Super be the Monk?
Feel like I am missing something obvious here....
Compare what the monk can and can't do with what JS said they did do | |
|
| PS: Fortune teller has a red herring. Got to get to work. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by chyperhondriac
Compare what the monk can and can't do with what JS said they did do
ahh yes d'oh | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by pleasantsurprise
Your night 1 result is correct. Your night 2 result looks wrong (despite Super?s play) because I don?t believe BS is the Demon. Han, sorry but can you remind me what your Night 1 result was again please.
Something happened to make your night 2 result wrong.
I assume you mean someone else, but you asked me? I was killed in Town at the end of Day 1 with only knowing either yourself or Berrystraw was the Drunk.
I'm seriously doubting the idea BS is a Demon but will run over several scenarios later to assume this.. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by pleasantsurprise
Your night 1 result is correct. Your night 2 result looks wrong (despite Super?s play) because I don?t believe BS is the Demon. Han, sorry but can you remind me what your Night 1 result was again please.
Something happened to make your night 2 result wrong.
OK, I couldn't remember as I was typing that post but I've sussed it now. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by Euro
Why do you think Night 2 is wrong?
Because I believe both BS and Super are on the Good side. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by HanSo7o
I assume you mean someone else, but you asked me? I was killed in Town at the end of Day 1 with only knowing either yourself or Berrystraw was the Drunk.
I'm seriously doubting the idea BS is a Demon but will run over several scenarios later to assume this..
Yes I remembered later.
I doubt very much that BS is the Demon | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by Firesilver
PS: Fortune teller has a red herring. Got to get to work.
Yes, a further complication.
Did either of the respnses from TG mention a red herring?
Or did you get a yes or a no and you have to decide which player name is either the demon or red herring in the case of a yes response? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by AndyP
Wow...I've just read all the posts. I think it's on me to reveal my role then.
I've never played this before so don't know if this is a good idea or not.
I'm the investigator so got an idea of who the minion might be.
If you are the Investigator, why didnt you say anything when it looked like Firesilver was the Investigator? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by Firesilver
I'm going to leave the rest of the town to decide on whether I'm too suspicious to be allowed to live, but I will say one last thing before work.
If you leave me alive for now, and lynch me if I'm still alive when there's 3 players left... well, the Demon then has to decide whether to kill me at night (to remove my powerful role from finding him) or leave me alive (in the hope that he also reaches the last 3 players and gets an easy win by getting the rest of the town to vote me off).
That's the only good thing that I can see coming out of this.
Oh yes, and Andy, if you could reveal all your information now, that would be great please. We've already seen that Investigator is an easy role to bluff if you only reveal partial information. What were your two names and what role is the minion, please?
Yes, Andy. Revealing all your info will be very helpful. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by JustSuper
If you are the Investigator, why didnt you say anything when it looked like Firesilver was the Investigator?
Good question Super. | |
|
| I reckon the bad guys will claim a 'Top 4 role' so they don't have to keep coming up with actions and results. | |
|
|
