| Quote: Originally posted by pleasantsurprise
Good question Super.
I think you're assuming I know what I'm doing  Plus there was confusion if FS ever said he was an investigator. I was trying to get to the bottom of that. I think it was Chyper that said he was  | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by AndyPI think you're assuming I know what I'm doing Plus there was confusion if FS ever said he was an investigator. I was trying to get to the bottom of that. I think it was Chyper that said he was Quote: Originally posted by Firesilver
Right, time for me to get to business.
As I mentioned yesterday, I need to whisper BlueBoar quickly to follow up on something I whispered to him on Day 1, but I am going to share the following information as promised:
Pleasantsurprise was one of the two names in my PM on Night 1.
The other name in my PM I'm not revealing yet, for reasons that will become clear later in the game. Suffice to say, right now, I do not think they are the minion (although I could be wrong!)
I would advise our undertaker (if we have one) not to reveal HanSo7o's character UNLESS your result tells you specifically that he was the minion (which would require a combination of character roles that is possible, but highly unlikely in my opinion). If he was the minion, Berry is probably the demon, and I'm just plain wrong (perhaps drunk). If Han was telling the truth (and for now we probably assume he was, given that he sacrificed himself willingly, he could have tied the vote yesterday if he'd wanted to) then Berry is probably good after all (albeit probably also drunk).
On top of the fact that I'm incredibly suspicious of how PS has played throughout the game, and my Night 1 result telling me he could be the minion, if he dies and flips not drunk, Berry will then know he is drunk. We'd have 2 almost-confirmed town players in Han and Berry. We may also then learn other information as well depending on other people's roles and information.
There is another thing that gives me an inkling about PS being the minion as well, but it's not time to share that yet either.
So go on then, PS. What exactly have you been up to this game, hmm?
So did you fail to see this post or did you assume he had a role different to that of an Investigator? Surely even if there was confusion about it, you would have said something to clear things up? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by AndyPFor me, not enough info to vote on anyone nominated really. My voting for BS was gut instinct - didn't like the stirring going on
On page 14 you posted this which was after hyper said FS was the Investigator and before FS came out and said he lied about being the Investigator. Im sorry but "trying to get to the bottom of it" I dont think covers it here as im pretty sure there can only be 1 Investigator. If you were truly the Investigator that could of been a "aha" moment where you could of in theory caught Firesilver out. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by pleasantsurprise
Yes, Andy. Revealing all your info will be very helpful.
Looks like you missed this Andy. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by AndyP
Wow...I've just read all the posts. I think it's on me to reveal my role then.
I've never played this before so don't know if this is a good idea or not.
I'm the investigator so got an idea of who the minion might be.
If you fail to divulge, after your statement and the Day phase ends... you will either be a target tonight or we will lynch you tomorrow.
Your choices are limited once you made that statement...  | |
|
| Quite a lot of reading to find out I have a Monk twin!
And that I have been nominated.
Night two I protected BerryStraw as I believe him to be townfolk. This plan obviously was the wrong strategy but I never expected Euro to get killed.
I have whispered with 4 players so far and I was able to guess one role, so I feel good about them. Another play has confirmed there role to me, but I don't see it as beneficial for them for me to confirm here. It is a useful town role that
Tonight if I live I will try to protect a non-top 4 role. Or maybe fake out the Demon to have him waste an execution.
I don't understand Just Super claiming my role, but my guess is he has a similar role such as a Soldier - I will study the character list more. I used Soldier as one of my 'Top 3' role in my Whisper as they had similar characteristics.
AndyP - My understanding is you know what type of minion is in the game (unless you were poisoned, and you will 'know a lie', but by that definitiojn it would be the poisoner).
Please let us know! I previously laid out my logic to suggest there is no Baron (99% sure). If we have a scarlett woman (20%)- HanSo70 may have been the Demon (small chance... like 0%). If we have a spy they have tons of information and register as good. No one has pertended to be the undertaker though... so less likely? (35%), Or a poisoner (45%), and this combo'd with a drunk is very bad news! | |
|
| Question for BB. I wanted to whisper you after I finished my whisper with HanSo7o, but unfortunately the window closed even before we could finish (we were both out today). It's about this post of yours:
Quote: Originally posted by BlueBoarHas PS been taking tips from Sadiq Khan perhaps? 
As it's a reference to the mayor of London, a) do you believe the mayor is in play and b) PS is the mayor? If my interpretation of your post is correct, why would you think so?
It bothers me, even more after PS claimed empath not much later. | |
|
| Nice to have the support of the two dead players
| |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by BerryStraw
Question for BB. I wanted to whisper you after I finished my whisper with HanSo7o, but unfortunately the window closed even before we could finish (we were both out today). It's about this post of yours:
As it's a reference to the mayor of London, a) do you believe the mayor is in play and b) PS is the mayor? If my interpretation of your post is correct, why would you think so?
It bothers me, even more after PS claimed empath not much later.
Now I'm at a true disadvantage! Local politics are in play! How well do y'all know the Monks of Canada? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by fedyshen
Quite a lot of reading to find out I have a Monk twin!
And that I have been nominated.
Night two I protected BerryStraw as I believe him to be townfolk. This plan obviously was the wrong strategy but I never expected Euro to get killed.
I have whispered with 4 players so far and I was able to guess one role, so I feel good about them. Another play has confirmed there role to me, but I don't see it as beneficial for them for me to confirm here. It is a useful town role that
Tonight if I live I will try to protect a non-top 4 role. Or maybe fake out the Demon to have him waste an execution.
I don't understand Just Super claiming my role, but my guess is he has a similar role such as a Soldier - I will study the character list more. I used Soldier as one of my 'Top 3' role in my Whisper as they had similar characteristics.
AndyP - My understanding is you know what type of minion is in the game (unless you were poisoned, and you will 'know a lie', but by that definitiojn it would be the poisoner).
Please let us know! I previously laid out my logic to suggest there is no Baron (99% sure). If we have a scarlett woman (20%)- HanSo70 may have been the Demon (small chance... like 0%). If we have a spy they have tons of information and register as good. No one has pertended to be the undertaker though... so less likely? (35%), Or a poisoner (45%), and this combo'd with a drunk is very bad news!
Interesting that you are claiming to be a Monk...my theory is that you are the Saint trying to get the demon to waste his kill on you. Or you are a Soldier trying to get the demon to waste his time or a kill (Im not sure if the demons kill gets used up if he tries to kill the Soldier). | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by fedyshen
Now I'm at a true disadvantage! Local politics are in play! How well do y'all know the Monks of Canada?
Don't worry too much, I'd say. From where we stand right now I'm pretty sure most of us see why executing you isn't the way to go for today.
Question is who to send to the block instead. I think we should await replies from Andy and BB at least before we decide on that, though. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by JustSuper
Interesting that you are claiming to be a Monk...my theory is that you are the Saint trying to get the demon to waste his kill on you. Or you are a Soldier trying to get the demon to waste his time or a kill (Im not sure if the demons kill gets used up if he tries to kill the Soldier).
So you are sticking to your claim to be the Monk? Surprising.
I wanted to bluff, but everyone decided to start playing cards down!
I am the Monk, could it get me killed, maybe, but I think there are more powerful roles (people who gather knowledge daily) that will keep me lower on the list. First night I had 9 people to choose from, and failed. Slightly better odds for me to help tonight, but still not the biggest threat to the Demon (in my opinion). | |
|
| Hi guys,
Apologies for my absense since this morning. I need to catch up on proceedings and I see we have nominated Fedyshen for the block. Why him?
I need to eat, water the garden and pack, as I will be away for a few days from tomorrow (I will have access to this site though, I hope).
Back soon. | |
|
| I think we know 100% we have a drunk. So that leave 1 more outsider (as there is no Baron as I previously pointed out).
As stated previously and no one noticed or disagreed with me, I can't see a Butler in play - Just from the voting patterns 9possoble - 5% change?
So really its Recluse or Saint. Is TG2 mad enough to have a drunk, recluse, a redherring (only for the Fortune Teller) and possible poisoner? I say its unlikely. So I think we do have a Saint.
Now if I live, who do I need to try and save tonight... | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by BlueBoarWhy him?
Why not? What has fedyshen done to earn trust? | |
|
| Interesting developments. Once again I don?t have time to post my full thoughts until I get home.
My results were ?No, you learn that neither of them are the Demon? on night 1 (PS and BB) and ?Yes, you learn that one of them is the Demon? on night 2. Nothing about a red herring other than in my role description. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by chyperhondriac
Why not? What has fedyshen done to earn trust?
With my theory of FedyShen being the Saint i think it would be way too risky to execute him as we could immediately lose the game. He may not have done anything to earn trust but he has not done much to earn distrust either. Lets just execute AndyP. His actions are suspicious and he has not even revealed the 2 players that could be minions. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by Firesilver
Interesting developments. Once again I don?t have time to post my full thoughts until I get home.
My results were ?No, you learn that neither of them are the Demon? on night 1 (PS and BB) and ?Yes, you learn that one of them is the Demon? on night 2. Nothing about a red herring other than in my role description.
Thats what i was assuming to be fair. For night 2 to obtain the red herring. Its either that or Berrystraw is the demon. | |
|
| If it helps my 2 minion suspects were BB and BS and we have a poisoner in play. I could have been poisoned or drunk I suppose but that's what I've got.
How about sharing some info yourselves JS and Chyper? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by AndyP
If it helps my 2 minion suspects were BB and BS and we have a poisoner in play. I could have been poisoned or drunk I suppose but that's what I've got.
How about sharing some info yourselves JS and Chyper?
What else do you want me to share? I have already said I am the Monk and theres not really much else I can share really. | |
|
|
