| Quote: Originally posted by AndyP
If it helps my 2 minion suspects were BB and BS and we have a poisoner in play. I could have been poisoned or drunk I suppose but that's what I've got.
How about sharing some info yourselves JS and Chyper?
I think it is impossible for you to be drunk.... or should I say unlikely. It would require HanSo7o to have been poisoned on night 1 and get wrong info about the Drunk (PS and BS if I remember right)
Poisoned, well maybe. Although I have good feelings about both BB and BS as town.
If only lying was impossible... this would be so much simpler! | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by AndyP
If it helps my 2 minion suspects were BB and BS and we have a poisoner in play. I could have been poisoned or drunk I suppose but that's what I've got.
How about sharing some info yourselves JS and Chyper?
You know I'm the Gunslinger. I had a couple of whispers but I didn't really glean much from them. It's difficult to exchange information when everyone already knows what you have to offer. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by fedyshenNice to have the support of the two dead players
depending upon how you vote in the nominations, that could change lol... | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by pleasantsurprise
Damn! I?ve missed where everyone else has revealed their roles.
What? They haven?t? They?re all being a bit cagey? Well I never! You do however, expect me to tell everyone what my role is. I wonder why?
BS, care to elaborate?
Blimey, I don't think I have ever seen you quite so tetchy.
In all honesty, TG2 said we should enjoy the game and I agree with him.
You of all people should be able to handle a little bit of pressure and come up smelling of roses given your ability to play these types of games.
Anyway, for the record and I mentioned this in a whisper to Fedyshen, than I do not 100% trust Firesilver. His confidence initially had me believing him, but the holes in his written prose started to show up and it left me less confident about whether he was straight up.
He has whispered me twice and gave me a big build up at the end of day 1 about the second whisper, which was a really hard read to be honest, but he'd thought it through and yada yada.
It will come as no surprise to you probably, that I was the missing person from his claim, but although he mentioned his claim about being investigator, he claimed this was a front for Fortune Teller, but I really believe this could be a bluff! Why?
In a 10 person game, a fortune teller would be extremely powerful and I just don't believe there is one in the game, especially with Chypercondriac arriving late as a traveller.
I wonder if Firesilver is the spy?
You're a lot better at this analytical stuff than I am, any thoughts? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by AndyP
If it helps my 2 minion suspects were BB and BS and we have a poisoner in play. I could have been poisoned or drunk I suppose but that's what I've got.
How about sharing some info yourselves JS and Chyper?
Well I never...
BB and BS - what do you make of Andy's results? | |
|
| If PS is the Empath (and not drunk), - He know FS and JS are town, He has stated he doesn't think JS or BS are evil (This was FS's night 2 fortune teller info - maybe he feels this from whispers but I'd love to hear why - I personally have a town feeling from BS, JS has claimed my role but also not voted to execute me... which I find odd) leaving myself a BB and the only options for Evil. (ignoring Chypher and the dead).
If he is drunk - Then we haven't learned much I guess | |
|
| This stuff is giving me a headache and I'm not involved with the game
Anyways good luck all | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by pleasantsurprise
Ok then, I?ll get the ball rolling.
The role I was given is the Empath
I was told that my neighbours were not evil.
If my role is true then FS and AndyP are off the hook.
If I am drunk, they may both be evil. Or only one my be evil.
Back to you again PS and there is something i think is not quite right here.
My understanding may differ from yours, so help me out here...
*If your empath result is true (not drunk or poisoned) FS & AndyP are not evil.
*If your empath result is false (drunk or poisoned) FS & AndyP are evil.
*Where is the part which determines only one can be evil??? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by pleasantsurprise
Well I never...
BB and BS - what do you make of Andy's results?
Today I read I might be the demon, or the minion, or the drunk, but my night 1 message told me I am town.
I have a lot of thoughts, but I would like to have an answer to my question to BB about you perhaps being mayor before I share about them. It would be great to know where he's got that piece of information from, if I understood the reference well. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by HanSo7o
Noticing the data FS is posting, so adding my own regarding other options if no further claims are made -
Hard to know what is who, even with the roles being claimed now - but as a Town, we should be in a better place. I'd be wary of making any nominations for anyone without further discussion please too...
I'm of the belief that we have a Drunk. Knowing who is the hardest... if not me, then who?
Example, PS is the Drunk - his info is wrong and those either side of him are null and void in roles of Town. This creates an issue with FS and AndyP. Neither of them have 'now' claimed a role. Firesilver making the bold 'tell' should have made him aware it could appear suspicious for him, even if it is good townplay. Any claims
FS has only whispered Blueboar, on both days... and only that player.
However, the following players have whispered him ; JustSuper, AndyP & PS.
PS has only whispered Firesilver on day one.
AndyP whsipered to him on day 2.
I'm of the feeling there is something amongst these. A Demon wouldn't want to reveal too many whispers and would encourage others to message him, if he knew their roles. FS has done this.. I cannot recall exactly who with, maybe AndyP, but the point being the Demon wants to remain hidden and IF in plain sight, even better.
Euro has whispered no-one.
Only two alive have messaged Euro, one being the gunslinger, the other Berrystraw. The other was me.
For the record, Firesilver claims he placed trust in me.
He was fairly adamant with everything he said and laid it out in extensive detail. So extensive in fact, that I really felt he knew everything there was to know about everything and everyone. I mentioned to PS that I believe he may be the spy and Fedyshen will verify from our whisper that I warned that I didn't trust Firesilver, despite everything he said and the faith he put into his whispers.
The bottom line for me, was he appeared to be trying too hard to be believable. It could be that the drunk influence was/is on his mind, but without the proof this is so, we cannot take that into account. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by BlueBoar
Back to you again PS and there is something i think is not quite right here.
My understanding may differ from yours, so help me out here...
*If your empath result is true (not drunk or poisoned) FS & AndyP are not evil.
*If your empath result is false (drunk or poisoned) FS & AndyP are evil.
*Where is the part which determines only one can be evil???
Reading the Drunk role description it says '...information will often (but not always) be incorrect'
I read that as meaning any info I get from TG (if I am drunk) may be wholly true, wholly false or partially true an partially false. (Because TG is an evil so and so) | |
|
| Maybe I'll share something I'm thinking, though. At this point PS and I both believe we are town, although one of us maybe/probably isn't. | |
|
| Going to bed shortly, so before I do.
Again, where is the other outsider?
Quote: Originally posted by Firesilver
I'm too suspicious now to be allowed to live to the end of the game.
Firesilver, if your mea culpa is as genuine as it is meant to be, then vote the right way on fedyshen and let me help you prove your innocence  then we can get on with the real nomination. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by chyperhondriac
Again, where is the other outsider?
Right here:
Quote: Originally posted by KaneWThis stuff is giving me a headache and I'm not involved with the game
Anyways good luck all
Joking. It's PS or me, but we are made to believe something else. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by FiresilverI'm stood in the shower, trying to cool down before going to work, and just feeling worse because I know that if someone else had played the game the way I have, I'd be immensely suspicious of them.
PS has a good result on me, but there's a 50-50 chance PS is drunk, so his information could be bad and it would be just like TG to sow doubt between two of the powerful town roles.
BlueBoar looks like the minion and I look like the demon- and to make matter worse, I whispered to him first thing on Day 1, making it look like I was sharing nefarious plans with him.
If I had just stayed quiet and played a safe fortune teller game, I could have probably got a third reading tonight and narrowed down the possibilities to a point where I could have safely been lynched to confirm my role and then we'd have been able to work it out from there.
Instead I had to be a smartass and play detective.
If you guys want to nominate me tonight, I'll vote in favour. I'm too suspicious now to be allowed to live to the end of the game. I'm going away on Monday to Wednesday anyway so the game would probably be better off without me in it.
And I thought Super was being the fool 
The plot thickens. Interesting that you throw my name out there as a minion, like you're throwing me under a bus or something. Quite the change from "before you post in the forum day 2, please whisper me because I have details which I think you'll like.
In all honesty, I don't think you are the demon, but I don't think you are trustworthy either. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by pleasantsurprise
Reading the Drunk role description it says '...information will often (but not always) be incorrect'
I read that as meaning any info I get from TG (if I am drunk) may be wholly true, wholly false or partially true an partially false. (Because TG is an evil so and so)
This was something I was aiming at a bit earlier when I asked about your second night information, but didn't finish because of life. Will the information be consistently incorrect? E.g., if a drunk 'fortune teller' asks about the same two players on two different nights, might they get different answers? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by BlueBoar
Blimey, I don't think I have ever seen you quite so tetchy.
In all honesty, TG2 said we should enjoy the game and I agree with him.
You of all people should be able to handle a little bit of pressure and come up smelling of roses given your ability to play these types of games.
Anyway, for the record and I mentioned this in a whisper to Fedyshen, than I do not 100% trust Firesilver. His confidence initially had me believing him, but the holes in his written prose started to show up and it left me less confident about whether he was straight up.
He has whispered me twice and gave me a big build up at the end of day 1 about the second whisper, which was a really hard read to be honest, but he'd thought it through and yada yada.
It will come as no surprise to you probably, that I was the missing person from his claim, but although he mentioned his claim about being investigator, he claimed this was a front for Fortune Teller, but I really believe this could be a bluff! Why?
In a 10 person game, a fortune teller would be extremely powerful and I just don't believe there is one in the game, especially with Chypercondriac arriving late as a traveller.
I wonder if Firesilver is the spy?
You're a lot better at this analytical stuff than I am, any thoughts?
Maybe FS is a Fortune Teller, but Cypher is a bad Gunslinger to balance out the game instead? Certainly could be something TG2 did to make the game more unpredictable. | |
|
| Aah the joys unfolding lol...
Note to self ;
PS is Drunk
FS - is evil
JustSuper is evil
Either AndyP or fedyshen are the finale..
Town were
Myself
Berrystraw
Blueboar
Euro
& Chyperhondriac
Ignore me all, or don't lol... but that's where I'm at.. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by HanSo7o
Aah the joys unfolding lol...
Note to self ;
PS is Drunk
FS - is evil
JustSuper is evil
Either AndyP or fedyshen are the finale..
Town were
Myself
Berrystraw
Blueboar
Euro
& Chyperhondriac
Ignore me all, or don't lol... but that's where I'm at..
I think JustSuper just told us we have to take out FS, Andy and him to win... | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by BerryStraw
Right here:
Joking. It's PS or me, but we are made to believe something else.
JS could also be an outsider, as we are claiming to be the same role. I?m not convince either of you are the outsider (yet). | |
|
|
