View forum thread

Weekends are not generally good for me, that's family time.

I don't think revealing my role and any info I have would be more helpful to the town than the Mafia at this point, so I won't be doing that. I still don't trust anyone, including Hanso, as his role is yet to be confirmed. I am inclined to believe Hanso though.

My main focus is on AndyP, he has info and seemed very keen to share it with FS on day 1, his reasoning being he did not know who to trust. He has whispered to PS today, but not come to me. He also has contributed little to the group in general but worst of all, voted down on Hanso as the penultimate vote which allowed me the opportunity to leave it as a tie. He has the chance to ensure we got a lunch and did not take it and has not offered an explanation for why he did this.

And where in FS?s post does he say he?s the investigator?

Also all role claims can (and should) be taken with a pinch of salt as things stand - the Mafia know which specific roles they can safely claim and it's very easy to hide behind drunk/poisoned results to look credible when actually throwing out bad info.

Based on the info provided by FS, what roles could he be?

Maybe no tips from Sadiq Khan, but PS has been reading Kafka a lot lately

Ok then, I?ll get the ball rolling.

The role I was given is the Empath

I was told that my neighbours were not evil.

If my role is true then FS and AndyP are off the hook.

If I am drunk, they may both be evil. Or only one my be evil.

Thanks, PS. I'll need a bit of time to get my head around what this means for the both of us. And for the others involved.

I believe I was the first person to mention Investigator. I said:

Basically - in so many words, more or less, implying without saying

If I read it right? - please tell me if you think I'm wrong or have misunderstood

I will admit I hadn't appreciated that there was another role that could have similar information but the mention of minion and poisoner in FS's post added to the implication.

However PS you have now claimed the other likely role. Did you get information last night as well?

That's what FS is saying. What if, for whatever reason FS is being economical with the actualite?

Hi Euro,

It's common knowledge I had information on day 1 and acted on it (as I think doing nothing is an own goal).
I'm still figuring out who to trust or not, so have not contacted anyone I have no clue about. Feel free to whisper if you want to start communicating...

I did yes, but because my neibours are still alive there was no change in th info. Ie they were boyth 'not evil'

Yes indeed, a possible bold demon play as I said, or a minion I suppose. Any other scenarios where FS might be muddying the waters that you care to elaborate on?

On another point - where is our second outsider? If we are playing with a drunk (which it seems pretty likely we are) then they won't know who they are. Where's our butler, our saint, our recluse? Surely the saint doesn't want us to execute them? Surely the recluse wants to clear their name?

One other point before I go out and melt in the sun this afternoon - I hadn't appreciated that the poisoner could actually before the game had started (i.e., on night zero). However, the combined probability of their being a poisoner and them poisoning a specific player is 1 in 32 by my calculations so I'm choosing to count that probability fairly low in my consideration of day one.

I also think someone said that poison lasts two nights but from my understanding it is one night and the day after, so you shouldn't have two poisoned players at once. TG, could you clarify for me please?

Or he could be a Good character and wants to put some players off the scent?

You are correct Chyper, the poisoning effect lasts from when the poisoner picks a player (poisoner acts first each night) until their turn the next night when they pick again and the previous pick becomes healthy again. Or, of course, it lasts until the poisoner dies if that's sooner.

If you want people to reveal roles before you reveal yours I will start. It will probably benefit the other Townfolk anyway and make them more confident in revealing their roles. I am the Monk.

What did you do with you ability last night Super?

Nominations are open.

I think its best not to get bogged down in what role Firesilver is. If he is revealing little information he may have a stronger role than a Investigator, therefore pretending to be an Investigator makes him not a target to the demon. I think its best to assume he is the Investigator, as whatever he is doing will benefit the Townfolk.

I protected myself since I didnt know any powerful roles to protect. I know I thought the Investigator was a powerful role, however I only realised Firesilver was the Investigator after Night 1.