| Quote: Originally posted by pleasantsurprise
What were your questions Han?
Learn anything to make you think you are the Drunk ? 
Feel free to contribute anything more too... | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by Firesilver
Me too! Just enough time to send it. I'll reply to you tonight when I get home from work.
Closing the whisper for now then. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by HanSo7o
It's an interesting thought...
You could be suggesting you are a powerful townie right here and now, but your earlier post moments before suggest you have nothing to offer. So, from my perspective, I'm wondering where you are heading with the question?
You also feel BS is mafia, and someone you do not trust etc.. be interesting to find out what you think after your current whsiper request with him too.
No-one yet to mention Euro is more suspicious of those posting here so far too lol...
Why are you talking? Arnt you supposed to be dead? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by JustSuper
Why are you talking? Arnt you supposed to be dead?
Either a clever post or you really haven't grapsed the difference between this and the mafia games. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by JustSuper
Just out of curiosity, if someone revealed their role and it was a powerful role it would mean the demon would try and kill them right?
Yes, but if the role is one that can be protected, then all is not lost. The object of the game is to make evil waste their kills by being better than them.
If you have a powerful role for example, you have to play the game to understand how everything works and even then, TG2 is the evil storyteller and will mix things up, so nothing is guaranteed. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by HanSo7o
Either a clever post or you really haven't grapsed the difference between this and the mafia games.
Sorry, im actually confused. Can you please explain? | |
|
| Ok, when any are killed we can still join in and make posts/whispers. Read the Intrustions more to discover this... however, any ability is no longer and my voting is limited. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by BlueBoar
Yes, but if the role is one that can be protected, then all is not lost. The object of the game is to make evil waste their kills by being better than them.
If you have a powerful role for example, you have to play the game to understand how everything works and even then, TG2 is the evil storyteller and will mix things up, so nothing is guaranteed.
But the Monk can only protect one person per night. What if two people need protecting at any one given night? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by HanSo7o
It's an interesting thought...
You could be suggesting you are a powerful townie right here and now, but your earlier post moments before suggest you have nothing to offer. So, from my perspective, I'm wondering where you are heading with the question?
You also feel BS is mafia, and someone you do not trust etc.. be interesting to find out what you think after your current whsiper request with him too.
No-one yet to mention Euro is more suspicious of those posting here so far too lol...
Quite right.
My initials thoughts about Euro, was I didn't want to be distracted by his inane ramblings about how the game was setup. He just went on and on pressing the point, which was most unhelpful.
What I will say though, is he was taken out by evil and would be Town or Outsider for sure and HanSo7o is to be commended for his sacrifice. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by JustSuper
But the Monk can only protect one person per night. What if two people need protecting at any one given night?
With the greatest of respect JustSuper, this isn't a PlayStation or Xbox game where you get three lives or something.
We only had 10 players, we are now down to 8.
One of those roles was Librarian.
The demon can bluff 3 roles knowing they are not allocated to someone and you're asking me "what if two people need protecting?"
Look, we can't play the game for you, because that means we have to carry you and I'm sorry, but I suffer with back trouble, so it won't be me! | |
|
| I assure I will not be the one being carried. Ive just realised FireSilver claimed to be the investigator yet the demon didnt try to kill him last night. Not saying im suspicious but any reason as to why no one attempted to kill him? | |
|
| If we assume FireSilver is telling the truth that means the demon found a victim thats worth more to kill (euro). If I remember correctly BerryStraw really wanted to vote out Euro and he also had whispers with him. What if euro told BerryStraw in his whispers he had a powerful role and Berrystraw decided to try and get other people to execute him. What if that did not work so he decided to kill him himself? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by BlueBoar
Look, we can't play the game for you, because that means we have to carry you and I'm sorry, but I suffer with back trouble, so it won't be me!
As TG2 said... Sowing confusion is a strategy. Either by evil or to try and stay alive on the good side. Would a demon want to kill someone doesn't know all the characters and how to play the game effectively? Would it also be effective to play aloof (even if it purely a strategy) on both good and evil side?
We won't know until the end.
What we do know if Euro was town (unless this is some very aggressive evil strategy that I can't picture). In all likelihood HanSo7o was town too. With our new player we likely have 2 evil, 5 town/outsiders and a traveler (likely a good traveler to keep the game balanced).
Euro only had 1 Whisper on night 1 (Berry), and was killed, while being limited in his gossip. I'm still trying to work on that theory | |
|
| Nah dont worry i got the hang of this now. Anyway ill be out for the rest of the day. Might be able to contribute close to midnight | |
|
| One question I have so I'll ask here.
A dead character gets 1 more vote throughout the rest of the game.
So if we were to execute someone tonight, 8 players remain. So we would need to get 4 hands up. But, presumably Euro and Hans have one vote to use wisely. Do we need to wait for them to say hands down in the order like normal (I would think so)?
Let me know TG2, or anyone whom has played before. | |
|
| FS, Chyper and Han, I will respond to you later.
For now I am enjoying a sundowner (or 2) in the garden.  | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by BlueBoar
[quote=HanSo7o]It's an interesting thought...
You could be suggesting you are a powerful townie right here and now, but your earlier post moments before suggest you have nothing to offer. So, from my perspective, I'm wondering where you are heading with the question?
You also feel BS is mafia, and someone you do not trust etc.. be interesting to find out what you think after your current whsiper request with him too.
Quite right.
My initials thoughts about Euro, was I didn't want to be distracted by his inane ramblings about how the game was setup. He just went on and on pressing the point, which was most unhelpful.
What I will say though, is he was taken out by evil and would be Town or Outsider for sure and HanSo7o is to be commended for his sacrifice.
Damn, harsh much. | |
|
| Still alive! And quite some discussion and whispering going on already this new day. Will read up and share my thoughts when I get home tonight.
I see Just Super cancelled his whisper request to me. Feel free to send another when you finish your current whisper. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by fedyshen
One question I have so I'll ask here.
A dead character gets 1 more vote throughout the rest of the game.
So if we were to execute someone tonight, 8 players remain. So we would need to get 4 hands up. But, presumably Euro and Hans have one vote to use wisely. Do we need to wait for them to say hands down in the order like normal (I would think so)?
Let me know TG2, or anyone whom has played before.
As a courtesy it would be good of them to state that they're not voting (or hand down) so that we don't all have to wait but mostly the new rule I added will cover it. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by TopGun2
As a courtesy it would be good of them to state that they're not voting (or hand down) so that we don't all have to wait but mostly the new rule I added will cover it.
As and when I see a nomination, I will most certainly let you and all know of any intention to raise my hand. | |
|
|
