View forum thread

You are correct - I wrote incorrectly.
It is either PS or Berrystraw that are the Drunk. And, as mentioned, myself can included in that, if I'm not the Librarian.

I do not believe there is more than one drunk, never said that before - just worded it badly in my last post.

There is no more to me than that.

Perhaps you would have felt better if I'd quoted your post and said 'I agree'?

At this point I can only hope that I'm the drunk...

No, I was just disappointed that you didn't have anything to add... you know, a theory, a counter-argument, some information you got from Firesilver perhaps?

I understand that's how you want to play the game for now & hope we start to find you more useful going forward.

Do you like tennis? I think we are on deuce... you're serving!

Haha!

I too, hope I'll be able to give more as the game progresses.

Being as cagey as FS, I'm not, at this stage, going to give anything away about our whisper.

I suppose that makes it

Advantage Blueboar

And the crowd groan with disappointment!

BerryStraw looks to be a stronger favourite for the block than Euro was as it stands. Why do you think that is PS? Come on... give it your best shot!

I like BS's fight though. Adding the JustSuper proposal for nomination may make a difference, but as he said... it's important that someone's head goes on the block tonight in this day phase! He probably wasn't expecting that to be his though when he said it perhaps?

My hand is up for BerryStraw. Do I know its the right move, no. Do I think JustSuper will put his hand up and get us to 5 (barring some changes in vote) in order to protect himself as he is now nominated, yes.

Lynching someone is encouraged as has been previously discussed, and if we are wrong I think TG2 has some power to try to keep the game balanced.

Will be interesting to see JustSupers defence and how the vote compares. I'm leaning towards hand up for JustSuper too.

[quote=BlueBoar]And the crowd groan with disappointment!

BerryStraw looks to be a stronger favourite for the block than Euro was as it stands. Why do you think that is PS? Come on... give it your best shot!

I like BS's fight though. Adding the JustSuper proposal for nomination may make a difference, but as he said... it's important that someone's head goes on the block tonight in this day phase! He probably wasn't expecting that to be his though when he said it perhaps?[/quotI have to admit there is a bit of 'Self Preservation Society' going on here.

IF Hans claim is true (and that's a big IF|) then either me or BS is anoutsider - probable drunk. I'd like to know one way or the other, if that's possible, by BS's elimination. If he's Town then either I am the Drunk or Hans is lying through his teeth.

That post didn't come out right but you'll get my drift

I?m at work and will post more in depth tonight, but I think the vote on Berry comes down to a simple question to Berry himself.

BerryStraw, do you think that, given that you?re going to have suspicion on you for the entire game, and given that there?s a more than decent chance you?re drunk and any information you are given could be tainted, would it not be better for the town to kill you now rather than having your continued survival causing confusion later in the game?

Speaking of self preservation...

Why isn't anyone nominating Han, actually? We'll get to know a bit more about his claim. And if his claim turns out to be feasible, we can deduct some things from there. Besides that, his ability has been used already, so it isn't that much of a loss. And if his claim turns out to be false, well, tears of joy.

If I'm not the drunk you wil want to keep me alive.

Damn good question BS.

Is it better to test the claim of one player rather thn the 2 he's incriminating?

I took the liberty of quoting my question and your answer with the name and quotes in the right place.

Yes, I agree that BS is doing that.

I'm also glad we share similar reasons for wanting BS eliminated from the equation. The outcome might not be what we want, but the purpose is to understand what has been happening since HanSo7o first claimed.

To add to that, I'm not expecting to be able to share much information anyway, whether tainted or not, given my character.

It feels like I'm oversharing now, but times like these ask for bold measures, I guess.

And if BS turns out to be Town then...

It would have been a better move to nominate Han than trying to throw JustSuper under the bus, I even accused someone of that as an easy out. But I hadn't thought of it until just now and I can't unring the bell.

A bit strange to say you will never see me again in your life but okay. To be honest these attacks do make you look suspicious in my opinion. And its not just me you have been attacking its Euro too, despite his willing co-operation when he was whispering with you. Its either you have the personality trait of someone who jumps to conclusions or you are Mafia in my opinion. Also how can you say i have vanished when its only been 24 hours?

Finally! You share something that actually contributes to the discussion!

This is true. If Han is the librarian. He is worth killing.
If he is the drunk, His is worth Killing (Likely even more so).

I'll nominate him and we will see how the 3 concurrent votes play out. Tie mean no lynching