| Quote: Originally posted by BerryStrawWell, it seems like a lot is going on here. I just read up on it and I must say I cannot get my head around a lot of things.
Euro was killed by the demon. What can we learn from that? I'm not sure yet, but I'd think figuring this out should be higher on our agenda than it is now. Any theories?
JustSuper is pointing at me several times already today. I would totally understand he's a bit grumpy about me trying to throw him under the bus yesterday. I'm not proud of it myself either.
So, JustSuper, I'm sorry for nominating you. I was trying to save myself, first by trying to turn the attention to Euro, and when that didn't work out by trying to shift attention to you. I shouldn't have played it like that and I apologize. Let's start over and enjoy this game, okay?
PS apparently showing up in both Han's and FS's messages as either being the drunk or the minion is very interesting. I hope we will be able to find out more about this, as it will give me information on whether I can trust my own character or not as well. Still, either FS or Han could not be telling the (full) truth about their roles, we should keep that in mind.
Besides that, welcome to the game Chyperhondriac 
In terms of Euro being killed by the demon it is a bit of a strange one. My theory was the demon finding out he had a powerful role, which lead to him killing Euro instead of the Investigator. I did think that could of been you as you did have whispers with him but maybe the demon is someone else and they found out his role another way. Worth noting the demon could have done this to confuse us.
Thank you for your apology, but as a Townie is it a good idea to reflect attention onto someone else? Surely if you are a Townie you would have preferred to make yourself innocent without complicating others because you wouldnt truly know who is good or bad. Despite being suspicious i will give it a pass for now as i need to focus on contributing and see what other people think about my theory.
You are also right in saying Firesilver may be lying about his role, but I have decided to trust him as i feel like i have to contribute in some way. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by BerryStrawIs that the real reason or are you sore about me finishing higher in the Bundesliga this season? 
Speaking of IAG influence PS better be careful before I return Rifat Drljich  | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by chyperhondriac
JustSuper - yes, and this is why I am coming down on the side of bad/unfortunate/other synonym townie play. Lurking evil would be saying something like, I don't know, making tennis jokes.
Firesilver - you made a point near the start that you were suspicious of PS playing the "so confused" card given their pedigree with these games. I had a similar thought when I saw it.
I found my tennis jokes on Trip Advisor. Coincidence?
Welcome to the game chyperhondriac.
On PS, it did come across that way, but whether it was intentional I don't know. He is a clever player, but maybe this took him out of his comfort zone perhaps? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by JustSuper
Thank you for your apology, but as a Townie is it a good idea to reflect attention onto someone else? Surely if you are a Townie you would have preferred to make yourself innocent without complicating others because you wouldnt truly know who is good or bad.
I understood I was in a hot spot from only a few minutes in the game, with HanSo7o directly pointing at my chair number and starting a whisper with me. I really thought I needed to act quickly, though lacked any information to go on, so I guess I was kind of desperate to find something against someone. I hope you'll understand and Euro as well.
Anyway, I'm still lacking a lot of information, so I guess the game is only starting for me now. | |
|
| I expect Whispers, posts and defenses to accusations to get tougher during the weekend.
Posts with a few beers (Pints!) my help unlock some answers though!
Whispers are open if anyone wants share some more delicate theories. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by JustSuperSpeaking of IAG influence PS better be careful before I return Rifat Drljich
PS is probably very sore about me taking 2 points of him on the final day, which meant he didn't win the Bundesliga title this season. He probably needed those sundowners. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by chyperhondriac
FS has claimed that they know two names, one of which is the minion - that's the investigator's power
Has he really? Missed that completely. Please quote where he said that. Thanks | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by BerryStraw
I understood I was in a hot spot from only a few minutes in the game, with HanSo7o directly pointing at my chair number and starting a whisper with me. I really thought I needed to act quickly, though lacked any information to go on, so I guess I was kind of desperate to find something against someone. I hope you'll understand and Euro as well.
Anyway, I'm still lacking a lot of information, so I guess the game is only starting for me now.
Bit ironic to come from me, but i will say it anyway. Seems like a bad townie play or a bad guy trying to get a townie lynched. Anyway ill put it down to a bad Townie play for now. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by JustSuper
I assure I will not be the one being carried. Ive just realised FireSilver claimed to be the investigator yet the demon didnt try to kill him last night. Not saying im suspicious but any reason as to why no one attempted to kill him?
His investigative role is a one shot only. He can't investigate anyone else, which is why the demon left him alone. Maybe he got a result with PS which differs from the other person he hasn't named yet perhaps?
Can I suggest you read the rules and roles to get a clearer idea of what's going on here. This is information you can get without having to ask for it. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by BerryStrawPS is probably very sore about me taking 2 points of him on the final day, which meant he didn't win the Bundesliga title this season. He probably needed those sundowners.
You can say that again BS.
*Grrr* | |
|
| If he is the investigator, which he has tip-toed around fully saying... The Recluse could cause him big problems (same problems caused for the Empath). TG2 may be as mean to us as the RNG that sends out injuries and red cards! | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by BlueBoar
His investigative role is a one shot only. He can't investigate anyone else, which is why the demon left him alone. Maybe he got a result with PS which differs from the other person he hasn't named yet perhaps?
Can I suggest you read the rules and roles to get a clearer idea of what's going on here. This is information you can get without having to ask for it.
FS has hinted he's got more to go at which doesn't seem like an Investigator Night 1 only role.
Again, whwre has he said he's the investigator and that he gets to know the name of a Minion?
You have to be very precise in sort of game. No-one can come ot with 'so and so said this' if thet didn't actually say that. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by Firesilver
On night 1 I was given information that one of two player names could be a minion.
End of day 1. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by Firesilverleasantsurprise was one of the two names in my PM on Night 1.
So go on then, PS. What exactly have you been up to this game, hmm?
Earlier today. | |
|
| Last one wasn't meant to have the
The posts are on page 11 & 12 of this thread, if you want to see the full versions. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by BerryStrawLast one wasn't meant to have the
The posts are on page 11 & 12 of this thread, if you want to see the full versions.
Has PS been taking tips from Sadiq Khan perhaps? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by BlueBoarHas PS been taking tips from Sadiq Khan perhaps?
Sadiq Khan?
Who he? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by chyperhondriacIndeed, it was a paraphrasing of the impression I got from your posts, not a direct quote.
In my mind there have been a few players who have been here without giving much away - PS, fedyshen, even BB. Then there's Andy who I haven't seen much or anything of in here, in spite of a few whispers.
Everyone knows my character so there's not much I can exchange with people in private or reveal on here. I guess that's the lot of the traveller - if I'd known I could have gone AWOL for several days maybe I'd have started from day one  | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by pleasant_2nd
FS has hinted he's got more to go at which doesn't seem like an Investigator Night 1 only role.
Again, whwre has he said he's the investigator and that he gets to know the name of a Minion?
You have to be very precise in sort of game. No-one can come ot with 'so and so said this' if thet didn't actually say that.
I agree, he could be in a similar role and trying not to confirm his exact role. Investigator is less likely to be killed. Him mentioning Minion, makes it not match up perfectly with the other similar roles, but again, this is a game of deception and all players, good and evil, have justifiable reasons to do so.
I don't want to say more publicly but there are few 'similar' townsfolk who get info on pairs and evil neighbours, etc. But his info rules out many roles (if not a bluff).
///
New aside.
I've studied the voting patterns, and although its not 100%, I feel we can assume we don't have a butler in this game (Yes then could PM TG2). Anyone have thoughts on this? Would be good to eliminate a few roles as not in use. If this is the case I don't think the Minion is a Baron (as there would be 4 outsiders) - From my Whispers I would say I'm 99% sure there is no Baron. (
- Related, I'm 95% sure there is no virgin.
And not very helpful, But HanSo7o wasn't a Saint. | |
|
| I know PS told Firesilver what he has been "up to", however Firesilver did say he thinks that the other person is not the Demon. Its already a 50/50 chance and with Firesilvers confidence shouldnt we just execute PS anyway? | |
|
|
