| Quote: Originally posted by HanSo7o
It's an interesting thought...
You could be suggesting you are a powerful townie right here and now, but your earlier post moments before suggest you have nothing to offer. So, from my perspective, I'm wondering where you are heading with the question?
You also feel BS is mafia, and someone you do not trust etc.. be interesting to find out what you think after your current whsiper request with him too.
No-one yet to mention Euro is more suspicious of those posting here so far too lol...
Maybe it is early in the evening... but I find so much suspicious now 
JustSuper requested a whisper for Berrystraw, and then cancelled once I made that comment noticing it. He has now mentioned he will be unavailable again, and requested a whisper with Firesilver, whom we know won't be online until around 2am. It's a nice 'out' for now hoping we won't all sit and wait - and find a different approach maybe.
PS has decided to enjoy the evening too, so we've lost another role for the here and now until later.
Granted real lives take precendence, and there are not likely to be rush nominations now we are two townies down, and have a gunslinger in town too.
Still no info is being shared to be known or confirmed (that I can see clearly), I feel the town are in trouble. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by Firesilver
It's very interesting that HanSo7o and BerryStraw are voting together on Euro and for what I personally think is a pretty flimsy reason. The sense that they are a pair is growing stronger all the time. I have further thoughts on this, but I think I'm going to wait for the results of the next night before I dig further into their relationship. (It is SO awesome that I don't need to worry about being killed tonight and no longer being allowed to ask questions or contribute, something that's always been in the back of my mind in previous mafia games.)
Did I miss something through your comment on not being killed last night FS... think I've skipped something here? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by HanSo7o
Did I miss something through your comment on not being killed last night FS... think I've skipped something here?
I think he just means that even the dead can contribute. So its liberating that you can die and still be a factor! | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by fedyshen
I think he just means that even the dead can contribute. So its liberating that you can die and still be a factor!
yeah, I began to realise after I posted.... unable to edit/delete it then... made myself look a fool slightly lol.. | |
|
| I?ve only got a little time on my break, but I?ve skimmed the thread and will share my thoughts in detail later.
For now, I was half tempted to refuse JustSupers whisper request, but maybe I can help him understand some things that he?s obviously missed in the role descriptions. AndyP, when you?re done with PS I would love to whisper you again please, again to follow up on something from our day 1 whisper.
Can?t wait to hear what PS has to say? and for Euro to share with us why he thinks he was killed! | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by Firesilver
Right, time for me to get to business.
As I mentioned yesterday, I need to whisper BlueBoar quickly to follow up on something I whispered to him on Day 1, but I am going to share the following information as promised:
Pleasantsurprise was one of the two names in my PM on Night 1.
The other name in my PM I'm not revealing yet, for reasons that will become clear later in the game. Suffice to say, right now, I do not think they are the minion (although I could be wrong!)
I would advise our undertaker (if we have one) not to reveal HanSo7o's character UNLESS your result tells you specifically that he was the minion (which would require a combination of character roles that is possible, but highly unlikely in my opinion). If he was the minion, Berry is probably the demon, and I'm just plain wrong (perhaps drunk). If Han was telling the truth (and for now we probably assume he was, given that he sacrificed himself willingly, he could have tied the vote yesterday if he'd wanted to) then Berry is probably good after all (albeit probably also drunk).
On top of the fact that I'm incredibly suspicious of how PS has played throughout the game, and my Night 1 result telling me he could be the minion, if he dies and flips not drunk, Berry will then know he is drunk. We'd have 2 almost-confirmed town players in Han and Berry. We may also then learn other information as well depending on other people's roles and information.
There is another thing that gives me an inkling about PS being the minion as well, but it's not time to share that yet either.
So go on then, PS. What exactly have you been up to this game, hmm?
Well I've been trying to work out who is good and who is evil. And you?
Some people have been posting drivel. Some people have been threatening to reveal information but never quite getting round to it for some reason.
I've practically told you the role I was given so you should be able to work it out. If you truly are good then the other person I referred to is also good.
UNLESS of course I am the drunk in which case one or both of you may be the opposite of what I told you. Bit of a conundrum eh? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by chyperhondriac
JustSuper - yes, and this is why I am coming down on the side of bad/unfortunate/other synonym townie play. Lurking evil would be saying something like, I don't know, making tennis jokes.
Firesilver - you made a point near the start that you were suspicious of PS playing the "so confused" card given their pedigree with these games. I had a similar thought when I saw it.
Where exactly did I say I was 'confused'? Please quote it for me.
What I did say was this:
Quote: Originally posted by pleasantsurprise
Like BB, I'm going to reread all TG's posts (yet again) to try and get a handle on things.
and:
Quote: Originally posted by pleasantsurprise
Especially for this whispering lark.
I mean , what are we supposed to say to each other?
*Hello [name] I'm on the good side. Are you?*
*Yes*
*Oh exellent. That's 2 of us then*
*End whisper*
It may become clearer to me on another read.
I followed that up with (Typos included!):
Quote: Originally posted by pleasantsurprise
I reckon reading TG's intros all tyhe time as the game progresses will be a must.#
I'm going to print them all out to have them in front of me.
and:
Quote: Originally posted by pleasantsurprise
I agree with this.
Having now read TG's post 'properly' (as opposed to skimming through as they arrive) I'm now in a better position to understand what's going on.
So in which post have I said 'I'm confused'. That same question can be directed at Firesilver who you seem to be following. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by HanSo7oLearn anything to make you think you are the Drunk ?
Feel free to contribute anything more too...
Oh Han, if you're privy to a way of determining whether a player is drunk or not please do tell. Me and Berrystraw would just love to know. | |
|
| So the only people to not vote to kill HanSo7o were:
AndyP
Just Super
Gentlemen, Any reasoning you'd care to expand on for this? Just a worse feeling on Barry? Or perhaps you have some other reasoning you'd like to share? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by HanSo7oMaybe it is early in the evening... but I find so much suspicious now
JustSuper requested a whisper for Berrystraw, and then cancelled once I made that comment noticing it. He has now mentioned he will be unavailable again, and requested a whisper with Firesilver, whom we know won't be online until around 2am. It's a nice 'out' for now hoping we won't all sit and wait - and find a different approach maybe.
PS has decided to enjoy the evening too, so we've lost another role for the here and now until later.
Granted real lives take precendence, and there are not likely to be rush nominations now we are two townies down, and have a gunslinger in town too.
Still no info is being shared to be known or confirmed (that I can see clearly), I feel the town are in trouble.
Bro why are you on my case all the time man lol. I requested BerryStraw because i wanted to question him as i was suspicious, but i realized I need to contribute more to the game so i have requested FireSilver instead as he is the detective and I have important information that I need to share with him. Also god forbid i have a life and decide to go out because its Friday evening.
Even if he was unavailable for a long time I would have still been able to whisper him tomorrow, however that is not even the case as he has just accepted so I am going to whisper him now. | |
|
| Also just to clarify i am replying a bit earlier then midnight as that is when i finished bowling with my friend...just in case anyone gets any ideas | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by fedyshen
So the only people to not vote to kill HanSo7o were:
AndyP
Just Super
Gentlemen, Any reasoning you'd care to expand on for this? Just a worse feeling on Barry? Or perhaps you have some other reasoning you'd like to share?
Well in my defense Berrystraw was saying things along the lines off "Im sure this is the last i will see of you". Is that really a normal thing to say if you are a townie? Seems to me Berrystraw was desperately trying to make me look like a bad guy but surely thats a bit too aggressive? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by fedyshen
So the only people to not vote to kill HanSo7o were:
AndyP
Just Super
Gentlemen, Any reasoning you'd care to expand on for this? Just a worse feeling on Barry? Or perhaps you have some other reasoning you'd like to share?
For me, not enough info to vote on anyone nominated really. My voting for BS was gut instinct - didn't like the stirring going on  | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by Firesilver
I would advise our undertaker (if we have one) not to reveal HanSo7o's character UNLESS your result tells you specifically that he was the minion (which would require a combination of character roles that is possible, but highly unlikely in my opinion). If he was the minion, Berry is probably the demon, and I'm just plain wrong (perhaps drunk). If Han was telling the truth (and for now we probably assume he was, given that he sacrificed himself willingly, he could have tied the vote yesterday if he'd wanted to) then Berry is probably good after all (albeit probably also drunk).
Seems like we may not have an undertaker. Unless they are speaking in Whispers (which is OK). The HanSo7o character info confirmed by the Undertaker would be very helpful to the townsfolk! | |
|
| I've seen a couple posts that say FS has claimed to be the Investigator.
Has he? Where has he said this? | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by pleasantsurprise
I've seen a couple posts that say FS has claimed to be the Investigator.
Has he? Where has he said this?
To be honest i saw someone else claim this so I went along with it. Also Firesilver has not denied it so im just assuming he is the Investigator. | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by pleasantsurprise
Where exactly did I say I was 'confused'? Please quote it for me.
What I did say was this:
and:
I followed that up with (Typos included!):
and:
So in which post have I said 'I'm confused'. That same question can be directed at Firesilver who you seem to be following.
Indeed, it was a paraphrasing of the impression I got from your posts, not a direct quote.
In my mind there have been a few players who have been here without giving much away - PS, fedyshen, even BB. Then there's Andy who I haven't seen much or anything of in here, in spite of a few whispers.
Everyone knows my character so there's not much I can exchange with people in private or reveal on here. I guess that's the lot of the traveller - if I'd known I could have gone AWOL for several days maybe I'd have started from day one   | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by pleasantsurprise
I've seen a couple posts that say FS has claimed to be the Investigator.
Has he? Where has he said this?
FS has claimed that they know two names, one of which is the minion - that's the investigator's power | |
|
| Well, it seems like a lot is going on here. I just read up on it and I must say I cannot get my head around a lot of things.
Euro was killed by the demon. What can we learn from that? I'm not sure yet, but I'd think figuring this out should be higher on our agenda than it is now. Any theories?
JustSuper is pointing at me several times already today. I would totally understand he's a bit grumpy about me trying to throw him under the bus yesterday. I'm not proud of it myself either.
So, JustSuper, I'm sorry for nominating you. I was trying to save myself, first by trying to turn the attention to Euro, and when that didn't work out by trying to shift attention to you. I shouldn't have played it like that and I apologize. Let's start over and enjoy this game, okay?
PS apparently showing up in both Han's and FS's messages as either being the drunk or the minion is very interesting. I hope we will be able to find out more about this, as it will give me information on whether I can trust my own character or not as well. Still, either FS or Han could not be telling the (full) truth about their roles, we should keep that in mind.
Besides that, welcome to the game Chyperhondriac | |
|
| Quote: Originally posted by AndyPFor me, not enough info to vote on anyone nominated really. My voting for BS was gut instinct - didn't like the stirring going on
Is that the real reason or are you sore about me finishing higher in the Bundesliga this season? | |
|
|
